Thursday, 9 July 2015

BALLYHEA VISIT TO BRUSSELS JULY 2015



'BALLYHEA SAYS NO' BANK-DEBT CAMPAIGN GROUP

PRESENTATION TO MEPs

EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, BRUSSELS

JULY 1st 2015

BACKGROUND
The Ballyhea protest began on March 6th 2011 and has been maintained ever since with a weekly march that now alternates between the village of Ballyhea and the town of Charleville, every Sunday morning.

During those four years and four months of weekly marches the group morphed from simply protesting to actively campaigning, very quickly realising that neither our government nor our media were going to be of any assistance to us.

This was the group's fourth trip to Europe to meet with the various institutions but the first visit by invitation and the first also specifically to meet MEPs.

The invitation came from the GUE/NGL parliamentary group via Luke 'Ming' Flanagan MEP and involved making two presentations. The first of those was in the morning, to the regular meeting of the GUE/NGL Group; the second was at noon and was open to all other MEPs.

MEMBERS OF THE TRAVELLING CORPS
Fiona and Rob Fitzpatrick; Cathleen Quealey and Pat Moloney; Frances and Pat O'Brien; Trish and Derek O'Dwyer; Sadhbh O'Flynn; Ellen O'Regan; Phil Ryan; Darragh Ryan; Joan Collins TD; Peter Mathews TD; Dr Constantin Gurdgiev (economist).

MEETING WITH GUE/NGL
First off it should be noted that even in the weeks leading up to our visit to Brussels, events in Greece were dominating  all else in the Parliament (understandably so) and in the GUE/NGL Group especially, of which Syriza is a member, with several high-profile MEPs. This then was always going to overshadow our presentation but so be it; our hearts are with the Greek people as much as our own, their struggle is our struggle and that was a point we would try to make.

We had 45 minutes to get our message across and so decided to focus on the most odious element of the bank-debt that has been forced on the Irish people, the Promissory Note bonds.

Luke introduced us to the gathered MEPs and/or their Parliamentary Assistants, and we were up and running.

I set the scene with a short Powerpoint presentation (Diarmuid O'Flynn by the way, penning this), which was split into three stages.

First, there was an introduction to who we are on the Ballyhea and Charleville campaign, those who had come to Brussels and those who would loved to have come but couldn’t.

SYMMETRY IN NUMBERS
Next came an outline of what we’re campaigning on, pointing out the symmetry in numbers between the total Troika loans to Ireland and the total bank bailout cost - €67.7bn and €69.7bn respectively – but more particularly, the symmetry in numbers between the bailout costs for three banks (Anglo mainly, but also INBS and Irish Permanent) and the entire tax take (income, corporate and capital) for the year 2010 - €30.85bn and €30.88bn respectively.
Neither pie very appetising - design Derek O'Dwyer

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
Finally, the big question – what was the point of making this presentation, where do we go from here?

Because it cannot initiate legislation but can only vote on legislation proposed by others (the Commission or the Council), the European Parliament has been described as the most expensive rubber stamp in history. Nevertheless MEPs do have influence and do have real clout.

In the first instance we asked that MEPs use every opportunity they can to include Ireland when they speak of countries affected by austerity and on this point, countering all the lies and spin about our phoenix-like 'recovery' from the ashes, we gave many current instances of real suffering and hardship in Ireland.

WRITTEN DECLARATION
On a more practical level, we asked that they support a Written Declaration on the Promissory Note bonds that we will be preparing over the summer break. The reason for not doing so immediately is that once it's been initiated, you then have just three months to get the required 50% of MEP signatures if you want to bring this to Plenary. Getting it there will be a challenge anyway (there are hundreds of such Written Declarations doing the rounds of MEPs here, all desperately seeking a signature, many of which – despite their worthiness – fail to do so); losing a third of the time allowed before we even start doesn't make any sense.

TASK FORCE - STOP THE SALE OF THE P NOTE BONDS
Separately, we are also in the process of putting a Task Force together which will focus on ending the sale of the Promissory Note bonds, with the aim ultimately of either a) their total destruction of the bonds or b), holding them in the Central Bank until they all die a natural death. It would also be our aim to recover the billions already destroyed in that process, plus the €3.1bn from the 2011 Promissory Note.

ELLEN O'REGAN - LETTER FROM AN EMIGRANT'S MOTHER
Following this, and the couple of minutes that surely made the greatest impact on all those present, Ellen O'Regan read from one of the letters we've received over the years on the effects of the fallout from the economic crash, the bank bailout, the subsequent unequally applied austerity measures. The letter was on emigration or more specifically, the effect of emigration on one particular family, penned by the mother.

Finally, Peter Mathews, Joan Collins and Constantin Gurdgiev spoke in turn, with Peter (a Chartered Accountant and former banker) highlighting how rules were bent and twisted to foist the debt on the people, Joan outlining the history behind the case she has taken on the legitimacy of the Promissory Notes (she is still awaiting a Supreme Court date for a final ruling on that), and Constantin looking ahead, sketching suggestions on what can now be done to stop the sale of those Promissory Note bonds.

Because our own presentation had overrun there was no time for discussion, which was unfortunate. Nevertheless it was a positive meeting, elicited a very positive response.

OPEN MEETING WITH OTHER MEPs
Our second presentation took place at noon and didn't have the numbers we had at the morning meeting. Nessa Childers (S&D) was there, as was Marian Harkin (ALDE); unfortunately that was it from either of those Groups – disappointing but understandable, given all that was happening with Greece, given also that S&D especially were involved in trying to find compromise wording on ISDS on the TTIP submission to the parliament Plenary session on the following week in Strasbourg.

All four Fine Gael MEPs were there, Sean Kelly, Mairead McGuinness and Brian Hayes staying for the duration of the meeting, Deirdre Clune offering her apologies for not being able to remain for the presentation but offering to meet us at a later date.

Also present were three UKIP MEPs.

The introduction to who and what we're about on this occasion was much shorter, though Ellen's reading of the letter again brought the place to a standstill, a tear again in many an eye.

Constantin went into much greater detail on his proposal on stopping the sale of the Promissory Note bonds, including addressing any and all concerns the ECB, the Commission or the Council might foreseeably have.

GIVE AND TAKE
With Luke in the chair, the discussion was then thrown open to the floor and first to speak was Brian Hayes. In the sense that he didn't point-blank shoot down what we're about, it was encouraging, and given that he was Junior Minister for Finance for a period in this government before being elected to the European Parliament, most of what he said was predictable, nothing that we haven't heard ten thousand times before, from our media especially.

It kicked off a lively debate in which Lynn Boylan (who had also spoken at the morning meeting) and myself both took issue with a few things Brian Hayes had said. 

MATHEWS GIVES IT BOTH BARRELS
Probably the most powerful intervention of all in this session however came from Peter Mathews, who didn't hold back in his assessment of how Fine Gael/Labour coalition has performed on the bank-debt issue, and on the Promissory Note bonds especially. There was a statement in there of how, biologically, men happen to be born with balls and a backbone but that in the case of this government, they have behaved like jellyfish. Doesn't read back as it sounded in Peter's very cultured south Dublin tone but believe me, it was all the more impactful for that!

Overall, and given the circumstances, we were satisfied with the visit, have come away with a lot of new contacts, new plans, very specific ideas.

A LONG AND LONELY ROAD
There is a sad note though, a persistently disappointing note. Four years and four months now we've been fighting this battle, 228 weeks marching, every week. And a few staunch allies apart on the political, economic and media front, and in Ratoath and Dublin on the regular weekly protest-march front, we're still more or less on our own.

We have seen this week what might have been achieved if our government had done what they promised in the elections they would do, and stood up to the ECB and the others in the Troika.

We know now that in the IMF, when it came to burning bondholders we even had an ally within that Troika.

WHAT COULD HAVE AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN


Tsipras and Varoufakis and his new government in Greece were in a much weaker position when they were elected five months ago than Kenny, Noonan, Gilmore, Burton and their new government – with its massive majority and massive mandate – was when they were elected in late Feb 2011; additionally, the Troika itself was in a much, much weaker position, as was the euro and eurozone.

Yet, judging that freedom, independence and dignity trumped the threats made by the Troika, Tsipras and Varoufakis choose to stand and fight for their people, while our government buckled, agreed to the debt slavery of generations.

THE NUTSHELL
Look, it's this simple:

  • In 2010, Anglo, INBS and Irish Permanent were already insolvent; 
  • The Promissory Notes were a workaround by all three of 1) the Irish Central Bank, 2) the then Irish government and 3) the ECB, of the ECB's own rule prohibiting use of ELA (Emergency Liquidity Assistance) for insolvent institutions; 
  • If the same thing were to happen today, a bank with solvency problems, there are structures in place at a European level to deal with it; 
  • It was the fault of the EU institutions, not Ireland's fault, that in the third year of the crisis there were still no such structures in place in 2010; 
  • Bailing out its creditors and saving those three banks – none of which was systemic in Ireland – was done to save the euro, the eurozone and even the EU itself; 
  • Halting the sale of the Promissory Note bonds would not impact negatively on anyone, anywhere, in the EU; those billions are already in circulation and forcing Ireland to borrow billions (which is what NTMA is doing, selling other bonds to buy out the Promissory Note bonds – have I lost ye yet???) to take those Promissory Note billions back out of circulation is simply a punitive exercise by the EU institutions at this stage; 
  • This can be done, easily and simply, and it would save future generations tens of billions in payments for debt that could hardly be more odious.


So why are we still so alone in this battle?




15 comments:

  1. TESTIMONY ON HOW I WAS RESCUED BY A GOD-SENT LENDER..

    Hello everyone, am writing this Testimony because am really grateful for what Mason Diego did for me and my family, when I thought there was no hope he came and make my family feel alive again by lending us loan at a very low interest rate of 2%. Well I have been searching for a loan to settle my debts for the past three months all I met scammed and took my money until I finally met a God sent Lender. I never thought that there are still genuine loan lenders on the internet but to my greatest surprise i got my loan without wasting much time so if you are out there looking for a loan of any amount i would advise you to email Mr Diego via: { diegoloancompany@yahoo.com } and be free of internet scams. thanks... Kathie Roper from California, USA.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Do you need an urgent loan to pay your bills and start up a new business??? Or you have been looking for a loan and you have always been scammed by a loan company or bank? Here is a chance to get your life back and get the funds you need to invest!!! Apply now Mr Johnson on Charitycorporationafrica@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. if you need a loan of any kind, whether long term, short term or medium term loan, contact me now via email with luckycreditfinance@gmail.com ,if you need financial assistance, contact me and i will help you out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good day,I am a registered private money lender. We give out loans to assist people, firms who need to update their financial status all over the world, with very Minimal annual Interest Rates as Low as 2% within a year to 30 years repayment duration period to any part of the world. We give out loans within the range of 5,000 euro to 100,000,000 euro. Our loans are well insured, for maximum security is our priority. Interested person should contact us via email:(24hourstloancompany1@gmail.com)

    Have you been turned down by so many banks
    do you need finance for the expansion of you business ,
    do you need a personal loan

    Apply for a loan, send down the details below:
    1. Full Name
    2. Address
    3. Amount
    4. Duration Period
    5.Phone Number
    6. Occupation

    Mrs. Farida Stephen

    ReplyDelete
  5. your loan problems might be, here comes your help as we offer loans to both individuals and firms at low and affordable interest rate of 2% Processed within 24 hours.and a repayment duration period of 1 year to 10 years to any part of the world.We give out loans within the range of 5,000 to 100,000,000 USD Just for only one fee, which is the Registration fee while the company will be paying all other fees, Any loan company asking for more than one fee is a scam and beware of that company. Our loans are well insured and maximum security is our priority.contact us today at(harry50loanfirm@gmail.com) where your needs are meet and your worries are over.
    YOUR DETAILS BELOW
    Full Name ...........
    Location ............
    country .............
    sex .................
    age .................
    Sincerely............
    Phone Number:...
    Loan amount:....
    Loan Duration:...
    Occupation:
    Monthly Income:....

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi everyone i once came across a blog about ATM hacking and how hackers have designed a means to withdraw money which is actually very safe to use. It came to a point when my pay cheque became so small that i needed extra cash and i was being skeptical about obtaining this card until a friend of mine Kim who has being using it for quite some time now and showed me a house which she had bought all from the proceeds of this card and i was really in awe and made contact for it via startechblankatmhackers@outlook.com and all i had to do was pay some amount for the card and its delivery to my address and in less than 6 days it arrived and boom i tested it to be very sure and behold i took out some good money. I am not here to tell you of its benefits cos thats self explanatory we all need some good money am only here to lead those in actual need of this card to the right source and waste no more money on some illegitimate company all in a bid to get the card. Contact startechblankatmhackers@outlook.com today and enjoy the best of trusted and transparent services.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm Sarah, and I want to share my experience here. I'm a single parent who was in a financial crisis, I couldn't pay the bills for my family,i started taking loans and borrowing from friends,eventually i couldn't pay back, I was so in debt, I even started looking for other alternatives,i heard about this BLANK ATM CARD , and i tried getting the card through various means, but I never got the card until a friend introduced me to CYBERTRON, an agency that provided me with this blank ATM card or programmed card that make withdrawal from any ATM machine. i then made contact and in exactly 6 days later my card and a manual was delivered to my home address here in the US. With this programmed card. I make cash withdrawals of 2000 dollars on a daily basis and 50000 dollars monthly.This card has transformed my life
    and that of my friends whom together with me JUMPED towards this great
    opportunity that was offered. For the past 3 months my life has never been the same I've been living the good life and I'm a living testimony. Should you be in need of this card contact cybertronblankatmhackers@outlook.com and get yours delivered to you within 7 days. They provide trusted and certified services

    ReplyDelete
  8. You can hack and break into a bank's security ATM Machine without carrying guns or any weapon.
    How is this possible? First of all we have to learn about the manual hacking of ATM MACHINES and BANKING ACCOUNTS HOW THE ATM MACHINE WORKS. If you have been to the bank you find out that the money in the ATM MACHINE is being filled right inside the house where the machine is built with enough security to hack this machine. We have developed the special blank ATM Card which you can use in any ATM Machine around the world. This card is been programmed and can withdraw 5000 USD within 24 hours in any currency your country make use of. The card will make the security camera malfunction at that particular time until you are done with the transaction you can never be traced. We are currently selling this black card at a give away price of $180 to serious minded people. If you need this card, contact me with this email: info.hackcreditcard@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. HACK ATM AND BECOME RICH TODAY!!!! AND LIVE A PEACEFUL LIFE, BEST WAY TO HAVE GOOD AMOUNT TO START A GOOD BUSINESS OR TO START LIVING A GOOD LIFE…. Hello everyone. There is a new way of making cash, although it is illegal but also a smart and easy way of living big. I used to be a street boy no food to eat until i became eager and decided to change my life one way or the other. I got no opportunity to enter works because no body want to help me i was sleeping in the park were car are kept. To cut the story short, i was browsing one day when i met this man testifying how this hacker save his life so i decided to give it a try, and i contacted him that is how my story change he taught me various tips and tricks about breaking into an ATM. with my knowledge, i have been able to counterfeit and program a blank ATM card using various tools and software’s. I have ready-made programmed ATM cards; I am just 29, my family are in USA and i have cash, i have a car, i live in Malaysia and i travel all around the world. i do my things on a low-key to avoid suspicion. Some of you will wonder why i am selling this out if truly i am already living large. It is because it is hard task doing it yourself, i wont lie to you, its not easy to hack ATM talk more of to programmed the card alone and be able to get $10,000 each day. It takes days and sometimes weeks you can get 70,000$. Some of you will want the ready made card to avoid the stress of doing it yourself and i don’t give the ready made card out for free because i spent days trying to make it available for you. e-mail me. hackblackcardservice009@gmail.comm of the ATM NOTE: the ATM card has no pin, no registered account number. It has no limit for withdrawal and it is untraceable. private email hackblackcardservice009@gmail.com

    EXPLANATION OF HOW THESE CARD WORKS……….

    You just slot in these card into any ATM Machine and it will automatically bring up a MENU of 1st VAULT #1,000, 2nd VAULT #5,000, RE-PROGRAMMED, EXIT, CANCEL. Just click on either of the VAULTS, and it will take you to another SUB-MENU of ALL, OTHERS, EXIT, CANCEL. Just click on others and type in the amount you wish to withdraw from the ATM and you have it cashed instantly… Done.

    ReplyDelete
  10. A lot of people have no idea about a working blank ATM card and a lot of people have been scammed in search of the Blank ATM card. It is longer news that CYBER ATM HACKERS (email: cyberatmhackers@outlook.com) is one of the few hacking groups that can provide you with a working Blank ATM card in anywhere around the globe. The programmed Blank ATM card can provide you with up to $2000 daily on any ATM without been caught. Those that require the Blank ATM card should look no further but contact us now (email: cyberatmhackers@outlook.com) and get working Blank ATM card within a week.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello my name is KELLY KLAUS MARIS , God has favour me, i want to let you all know that there are a lot of bad persons on the internet trying to get our money and not giving us what we ask for, i was financially strained few months ago, i lost my parents 4 years ago, and after that i was desperately in need of a loan because of my education, bills and some other things, i almost gave up on my education until one of my friend directed me to Mr. JAMES ELITE, who lend me a loan of $60,000 under three days. So for those that are out here like me, if you are in need of any kind of a loan just contact him now via ELITEFINANCE2000@GMAIL.COM OR ELITE_FINANCE@OUTLOOK.COM. I'm saying all of these because of the hell i passed through in the hands of my former phony lender and you know what.......... i don't wish my haters to go through such hell that i went through in the hands of those phony online lenders. Please once you get your loan from Mr. JAMES BENSON via: ELITEFINANCE2000@GMAIL.COM OR ELITE_FINANCE@OUTLOOK.COM also let others know, your friends, close ones, close ones. Mr JAMES ELITE is a blessing that God sent to me after all my relations couldn't help me. May God continue to bless him. PHONE NUMBER: +17472338177

    ReplyDelete
  12. BE SMART AND BECOME RICH IN LESS THAN 2 DAYS.
    It all depends on how fast you can be to get the new PROGRAMMED blank ATM card that is capable of hacking into any ATM machine,anywhere in the world. I got to know about this BLANK ATM CARD when I was searching for job online about a month ago..It has really changed my life for good and now I can say I’m rich and I can never be poor again.The least money I get in a day with it is about $100,000.(hundred thousand USD) Everyday I keeping pumping money into my account. Though it’s illegal,there is no risk of being caught,because it has been programmed in such a way that it is not traceable,it also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTVs to detect you..For details on how to get yours today, email the hackers on : (martinshackers22@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hello we give out loans to any country all over the word Are you looking for financial assistance,we offer a
    loan at a maximum low rate of 2%, both secure, every interested applicant should contact us with this Email:
    JAMESMOESLOANWORD@YAHOO.COM

    ReplyDelete
  14. CERTIFIED ONLINE BLANK ATM HACKERS, is the only genuine ATM cloned card vendor which i have tested and confirmed. So i met this hacker online and we emailed back & forth about an ATM card and how he makes them and sells them. I was in trouble financially two weeks ago so i told him i need one asap. I western union some money to him the next day, and the card was sent to me in 72 hrs. Instantly when i got it i went straight to a near by ATM which was across the street from my house and i asked for $3000 and it actually worked so since then I've been able to get money freely without trace. You can also get your card without stress, do contact the email: certifiedonlineatmhackers.org@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  15. I have being hearing about this blank ATM card for a while and i never really paid any interest to it because of my doubts. Until one day i discovered a hacking guy called MR CLIFFORD. He is really good at what he is doing. Back to the point, i inquired about The Blank ATM Card. If it works or even Exist. They told me Yes and that its a card programmed for random money withdraws without being noticed and can also be used for free online purchases of any kind. This was shocking and i still had my doubts. Then i gave it a try and asked for the card and agreed to their terms and conditions. praying and hoping it was not a scam i used the blank CARD and it was successful i withdraw nor less than $20,000 every day the blank CARD worked like a magic and now i have become rich and famous in my society, if you want to order for the blank ATM CARD here is there email address : cliffordhackerspays@gmail.com....

    ReplyDelete